Sterile allogeneic spongioflex® allografts as partial meniscal replacement after incomplete meniscal loss, an investigator initiated trial

2023-508271-36-00 Therapeutic use (Phase IV) Ongoing, recruiting

Start 30 Apr 2024 · Status Ongoing, recruiting · 1 EU/EEA countries · 1 sites

Overview

Sponsor-declared trial summary

Phase Therapeutic use (Phase IV)
Status Ongoing, recruiting
Participants planned 30
Countries 1
Sites 1

incomplete meniscal loss

The objective is to improve the meniscus functionality. The efficacy of the procedure will be evalated using the PROMS (IKDC, KOOS, VAS-pain-score). The comparison of the PROMs between patients operated and not operated will be performed and a comparison between PROMs at the beginning of the study and after 2 and 5 yea…

Key facts

Sponsor
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Knie und Schulterchirurgie
Participant type
Patients
Age range
18-64 years
Gender
Male and Female
Therapeutic area
Analytical,Diagnostic,Therapeutic Techniques and Equipment [E]-Surgical Procedures, Operative [E04]
Trial duration
30 Apr 2024 → ongoing
Decision date (initial)
2024-03-15
Transition trial
No
Low-intervention
Yes
Rare-disease indication
No
Vulnerable population
No
Funding sources
Dr. Behrendt, Praxis für Knie- und Schulterchirurgie

Trial design

CTIS Part I — objectives, methods, condition coding

Main objective

Scope: Efficacy, Safety, Therapy

The objective is to improve the meniscus functionality. The efficacy of the procedure will be evalated using the PROMS (IKDC, KOOS, VAS-pain-score). The comparison of the PROMs between patients operated and not operated will be performed and a comparison between PROMs at the beginning of the study and after 2 and 5 years. The clinical trial will be conducted in compliance with the protocol, the CTR 536/2014 and with this Regulation and with the principles of good clinical practice.

Secondary objectives 4

  1. Safety of the patient will be estimated by Type, frequency, and severity of treatment related to AEs and SAEs
  2. Efficacy of the procedure will be evaluated by answering the question: How many patients show a progression of osteoarthrosis up to TKA?
  3. MRI evaluation will be performed by Outerbridge graduation, size of meniscus, number of patients with extrusion, size of extrusion after 6 weeks, 6 and 12 months (for operated patients) and after 2 and 5 years, comparison between the operated and the non-operated group
  4. patient satisfaction using the satisfaction categories: very pleased, pleased, not pleased, very unsatisfied in the operated group after 2 and 5 years will be analyzed..

Conditions and MedDRA coding

incomplete meniscal loss

VersionLevelCodeTermSystem organ class
21.1 LLT 10072105 Meniscus tear 10022117
20.0 LLT 10012420 Derangement of posterior horn of medial meniscus 10022117
20.0 LLT 10012416 Derangement of lateral meniscus unspecified 10022117
21.1 LLT 10027291 Meniscus tear of knee 10022117
21.1 PT 10072970 Meniscus injury 100000004863
20.0 PT 10054948 Meniscus operation 100000004865
20.0 LLT 10012415 Derangement of lateral meniscus 10022117
20.0 LLT 10012414 Derangement of anterior horn of medial meniscus 10022117
21.1 LLT 10006534 Bucket handle tear of medial meniscus of knee 10022117
20.1 LLT 10006533 Bucket handle tear of lateral meniscus 10022117
20.1 LLT 10030263 Old bucket handle tear of medial meniscus 10022117
21.1 LLT 10031548 Other and unspecified derangement of medial meniscus 10022117
20.1 LLT 10012419 Derangement of posterior horn of lateral meniscus 10022117
20.0 LLT 10012418 Derangement of meniscus not elsewhere classified 10022117
20.0 LLT 10049474 Meniscus rupture 10022117
20.1 LLT 10031892 Other derangement of lateral meniscus 10022117
20.0 LLT 10012413 Derangement of anterior horn of lateral meniscus 10022117
21.1 LLT 10053777 Meniscus lesion 10022117

Study design 1 period

#TitleAllocationBlindingRoles blindedArms
1 surgery/no surgery
After initial evaluation for inclusion and exclusion criteria, the patient decides if operated or not
2 None operated: patient wil be treated with Spongioflex(R) for partial meniscal replacement,
functinality of the knee and MRI image will be evaluated
non-operated: patient did not decide for surgery,
functionality of the knee and the MRI image will be evaluated

Eligibility criteria

Principal inclusion / exclusion criteria as submitted by sponsor

Inclusion criteria 4

  1. Partial loss of portions of the lateral meniscus and lateral joint line pain OR - Partial loss of the medial meniscus and medial joint line pain
  2. Age 18-60 years
  3. written consent to the study and to provide the scientific data in pseudonymized form
  4. sufficient standing of the peripheral rim, so that the procedure can be performed

Exclusion criteria 11

  1. Presence of anterior cruciate ligament insufficiency that is not resolved by reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament within 16 weeks after partial meniscal implantation.
  2. only for patients who will be operated: - with increased anesthesiological risk, e.g. with known or predicted difficult airway - with increased risk of bleeding - with increased risk of infection - with necrotic, infected or poorly perfused host sides - history of allergic reactions or acute hypersensitivity reactions to the IMP or any of its excipients - pregnant woman
  3. Axial deviation (>2° varus or valgus)
  4. realignment osteotomy not performed within 12 weeks
  5. advanced cartilage damage (grade III according to ICRS) and osteoarthrosis in the affected compartment (grade III according to Kellgren and Lawrence (Kellgren and Lawrence, 1957)
  6. Extension deficit of more than 3° compared to the opposite side or a knee flexion of less than 125°
  7. BMI greater than 30 kg/m²
  8. <18 years, >60 years
  9. pregnancy (only for patients with surgery)
  10. Chronic pain patients
  11. inflammatory arthritis or synovitis on the treated knee

Endpoints

Primary and secondary outcome measures (English text)

Primary endpoints 1

  1. Improvement of PROMs (KOOS, IKDC, VAS Pain Score) 2 and 5 years after surgery compared to scores of the non-operated group and compared to pre-surgery scores.

Secondary endpoints 4

  1. Safety of the patient: Type, frequency and severity of treatment-related AEs and SAEs
  2. Efficacy of the procedure: How many patients show a progression of osteoarthrosis up to TKA?
  3. MRI evaluation: Outerbridge graduation, size of meniscus, number of patients with extrusion, size of extrusion after 6 weeks, 6 and 12 months (for operated patients) and after 2 and 5 years, comparison between the operated and the non-operated group
  4. Patient satisfaction: very pleased, pleased, not pleased, very unsatisfied in the operated group after 2 and 5 years

Investigational products

Investigational medicinal products (IMPs), comparators, placebo, auxiliary

Test 1

Human Cancellous Bone

SUB184038 · Substance

Active substance
Human Cancellous Bone
Pharmaceutical form
TRANSPLANT OF HUMAN ORIGIN
Route of administration
UNKNOWN USE
Max daily dose
1 U unit(s)
Max total dose
1 U unit(s)
Max treatment duration
63 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
- — -
Marketing authorisation
-
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Sponsors and contacts

Sponsor organisations, regulatory contacts, third parties

Dr. Sven Behrendt, Knie und Schulterchirurgie

Sponsor organisation
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Knie und Schulterchirurgie
Address
Hoher Wall 14, Mitte Mitte
City
Dortmund
Postcode
44137
Country
Germany

Scientific contact point

Organisation
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Praxis für Kien und Schulterchirurgie
Contact name
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Praxis für Knie- und Schulterchirugie

Public contact point

Organisation
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Praxis für Kien und Schulterchirurgie
Contact name
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Praxis für Knie- und Schulterchirugie

Locations

1 EU/EEA country · 1 investigational sites

By country

CountryMS statusPlanned subjectsSites
Germany Ongoing, recruiting 30 1
Rest of world 0

Investigational sites

Germany

1 site · Ongoing, recruiting
Dr. Sven Behrendt, Praxis für Knie und Schulterchirugie
Praxis für Knie und Schulterchirugie, Hoher Wall 14, 44137, Dortmund

Country notifications

Trial-start, recruitment-start, end and early-termination notifications submitted per Member State

Country Trial startTrial end Recruitment startRecruitment end Early termination
Germany 2024-04-30 2024-05-06

Results and documents

Annex IV summary of results, Annex V layperson summary, and all documents registered in CTIS for this trial

Documents 12 files

Public protocol annexes, IB summaries, regulatory submissions and post-authorisation documents registered in CTIS.

TypeTitleVersion
Protocol (for publication) CTIS_CRF_Form spongioflex_Vers_3_2023_11_23 3
Protocol (for publication) ICH_M11_Protocol_Version_5_2024_01_05_ 5
Protocol (for publication) IKDC_2023-508271-36-00 1
Protocol (for publication) KOOS_2023-508271-36-00 1
Protocol (for publication) Spongioflex_Adverse Event log 1
Protocol (for publication) Spongioflex_Serious Adverse Event log 1
Recruitment arrangements (for publication) recruitment_arrangements_en_Behrendt_for_publication 1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) Aufklarung_mit_Datenschutz_Version_4_CT_2024_03_11 4
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) Dabaghi_Eras_2023_Allograft for partial meniscus 1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) Justification German 1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) justification of Spongioflex use for non-bone structures_ 1
Synopsis of the protocol (for publication) PROTOCOL SYNOPSIS_2024_01_03_for publication 4

Application history

5 submissions — initial application plus substantial / non-substantial modifications

#TypeCodeSubmittedReference MSConclusionDecision date
1 INITIAL IN 2023-09-23 Germany Acceptable
2024-01-18
2024-03-15
2 NON SUBSTANTIAL MODIFICATION NSM-3 2025-04-04 Germany Acceptable
2024-01-18
2025-04-04
3 SUBSTANTIAL MODIFICATION SM-2 2025-04-07 Germany Acceptable
2025-04-14
2025-04-16
4 NON SUBSTANTIAL MODIFICATION NSM-4 2025-05-27 Germany Acceptable
2025-04-14
2025-05-27
5 NON SUBSTANTIAL MODIFICATION NSM-5 2025-11-16 Germany Acceptable
2025-04-14
2025-11-16