Trial of Sequential Medications AfteR TNFi Failure in Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis (SMART-JIA)

2025-520923-25-00 Protocol SMART-JIA Therapeutic confirmatory (Phase III) Authorised, recruitment pending

Status Authorised, recruitment pending · 3 EU/EEA countries · 3 sites · Protocol SMART-JIA

Overview

Sponsor-declared trial summary

Phase Therapeutic confirmatory (Phase III)
Status Authorised, recruitment pending
Participants planned 90
Countries 3
Sites 3

Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis

To evaluate the comparative effectiveness of treatment with each of 3 non-TNFi medications individually vs. treatment with a second TNFi to achieve minimal disease activity (MiDA; cJADAS10 less or equal to 5) at 6 months in children with Polyarticular course juvenile idiopathic arthritis (pcJIA) refractory to pre-trial…

Key facts

Sponsor
Duke Clinical Research Institute
Participant type
Pediatric, Patients
Age range
0-17 years
Gender
Male and Female
Therapeutic area
Diseases [C] - Immune System Diseases [C20]
Decision date (initial)
2026-02-11
Transition trial
No
Low-intervention
Yes
Rare-disease indication
No
Vulnerable population
Yes
Funding sources
Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI)

External identifiers

EU CT number
2025-520923-25-00
WHO UTN
U1111-1322-4869
ClinicalTrials.gov
NCT06654882

Trial design

CTIS Part I — objectives, methods, condition coding

Main objective

Scope: Therapy

To evaluate the comparative effectiveness of treatment with each of 3 non-TNFi medications individually vs. treatment with a second TNFi to achieve minimal disease activity (MiDA; cJADAS10 less or equal to 5) at 6 months in children with Polyarticular course juvenile idiopathic arthritis (pcJIA) refractory to pre-trial TNFi treatment. The primary hypothesis is to establish superiority by showing that a higher proportion of children in each of the 3 non-TNFi treatment groups achieve MiDA at 6 months compared to children treated with a second TNFi.

Secondary objectives 3

  1. To compare patient and caregiver reported outcomes (PROs [PROMIS® pain interference, fatigue, and mobility measures]) and change in arthritis disease activity (cJADAS10 and JIA American College of Rheumatology Pediatric 70 [ACR 70]) after treatment with each of 3 non-TNFi medications vs. treatment with a second TNFi at 6 months.
  2. To evaluate the treatment strategies embedded in the SMART design at 12 months, where a treatment strategy comprises a sequence of a non-TNFi or second TNFi medication followed by a subsequent medication for poor responders.
  3. To optimize study recruitment and retention by identifying barriers and developing improved patient-facing materials and processes using Design Thinking methods.

Conditions and MedDRA coding

Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis

VersionLevelCodeTermSystem organ class
23.1 PT 10059176 Juvenile idiopathic arthritis 100000004859

Eligibility criteria

Principal inclusion / exclusion criteria as submitted by sponsor

Inclusion criteria 6

  1. Polyarticular course JIA
  2. Moderate or high-disease activity (cJADAS10 >5) despite treatment with an initial TNFi for greater than or equal to 3 months
  3. Age higher or equal to 2 years and <18 years and weight greater than or equal to 10 kg
  4. No systemic glucocorticoids or systemic glucocorticoids at a stable dose of less or equal to 0.2 mg/kg/day (maximum 10 mg/day) for more or equal to 2 weeks prior to baseline visit
  5. Documented informed consent/assent obtained from the parent/caregiver/patient
  6. Females of childbearing potential are eligible only if they agree to use the required contraception methods or are not sexually active

Exclusion criteria 22

  1. Systemic JIA
  2. Prior treatment with non-TNFi bDMARDs and/or any JAKi
  3. Aspartate aminotransferase (AST) or alanine transaminase (ALT) greater than or equal to 1.5 x upper limit of normal (ULN) for age and sex
  4. Serum creatinine > 1.5 x ULN for age and sex
  5. Platelet count <150 x 10^3/microlitre (<150,000/mm^3)
  6. Hemoglobin less than or equal to 9.0 g/dL (less than or equal to 5.6 mmol/L)
  7. White blood cell (WBC) count <3,000/mm^3 (<3.0 x 10^9/L)
  8. Neutrophil count less than or equal to 2000/mm^3 (less than or equal to 2.0 x 10^9/L)
  9. Absolute lymphocyte count less than or equal to 500 cells/m^3
  10. Any active acute, subacute, chronic, or recurrent bacterial, viral (including HIV, HCV, and HBV), or systemic fungal infection or any major episode of infection requiring hospitalization or treatment during screening or treatment with IV antibiotics completed within 4 weeks of the screening visit or oral antibiotics completed within 2 weeks of the screening visit. HBsAg positive and HBcAb negative: Participant is excluded from study. HBsAg negative and HBcAb positive and HBsAb negative: Participant is excluded from study. HCV Ab positive and HCV RNA positive: Participant is excluded from study (HCV RNA sample collection may be deferred and collected only if required to confirm eligibility in HCV Ab positive patients). HIV-1 or HIV-2 antibody positive: Participant is excluded from study.
  11. Any medical history considered a contraindication/safety concern by the study investigator with the use of adalimumab, etanercept, tofacitinib, ABA, or an IL-6 inhibitor or their biosimilars. In particular, subjects at high risk for venous thromboembolism will be excluded. A subject may be at high risk for venous thromboembolism if they: - have heart failure or prior myocardial infarction within past 3 months; -have inherited coagulation disorders;-have had venous thromboembolism, either deep venous thrombosis or pulmonary embolism; -are undergoing major surgery or is immobilized.
  12. Enthesitis-related arthritis/juvenile spondyloarthritis (2001 International League of Associations for Rheumatology [ILAR] criteria)
  13. Pregnant or breastfeeding
  14. History of or currently active inflammatory bowel disease
  15. History of or currently active psoriasis
  16. Active uveitis within 3 months of the baseline visit
  17. History of or currently active sacroiliitis
  18. History of or current malignancy
  19. Active tuberculosis (TB) or a history of incompletely treated TB; Purified Protein derivative (PPD) or QuantiFERON-TB positive patients (without active TB) unless it is documented that the patient has been adequately treated for TB and can start treatment with a biologic agent, based on the medical judgment of the site investigator and/or an infectious disease specialist; suspected extrapulmonary TB infection; or at high risk of contracting TB, such as close contact with individual with active or latent TB.
  20. Prior treatment with more than one TNFi molecule; exposure to more than one biosimilar of the same TNFi molecule is allowed
  21. Any live attenuated vaccine, such as varicella-zoster, oral polio, measles, mumps or rubella vaccines, within 4 weeks prior to the baseline visit and throughout the study. Killed or inactive vaccine may be permitted based on the investigator’s judgment.
  22. History of hypersensitivity or allergic reaction to any study drug or any of its excipients (inactive ingredients).

Endpoints

Primary and secondary outcome measures (English text)

Primary endpoints 1

  1. Minimal disease activity (MiDA) at Month 6 as assessed by the cJADAS10 less than or equal to 5

Secondary endpoints 5

  1. PROMIS® pain interference at Month 6
  2. PROMIS® fatigue at Month 6
  3. PROMIS® mobility at Month 6
  4. Change in arthritis disease activity (cJADAS10 and JIA American College of Rheumatology Pediatric 70 [ACR 70]) at Month 6
  5. Change in arthritis disease activity (cJADAS10) at Month 12

Investigational products

Investigational medicinal products (IMPs), comparators, placebo, auxiliary

Test 6

XELJANZ 1 mg/mL oral solution

PRD9172022 · Product

Active substance
Tofacitinib
Substance synonyms
CP-609,550, TASOCITINIB
Pharmaceutical form
ORAL SOLUTION
Route of administration
ORAL
Max daily dose
10 mg/ml milligram(s)/millilitre
Max total dose
10 mg/l milligram(s)/litre
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AF01 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/17/1178/015
MA holder
PFIZER EUROPE MA EEIG
MA country
Liechtenstein
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

XELJANZ 5 mg film-coated tablets

PRD4862227 · Product

Active substance
Tofacitinib
Pharmaceutical form
FILM-COATED TABLET
Route of administration
ORAL
Max daily dose
10 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
10 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AF01 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/17/1178/002
MA holder
PFIZER EUROPE MA EEIG
MA country
Iceland
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

ORENCIA 50 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD7240744 · Product

Active substance
Abatacept
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
125 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
125 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AA24 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/07/389/013
MA holder
BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB PHARMA EEIG
MA country
EU
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

ORENCIA 125 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD2316715 · Product

Active substance
Abatacept
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
125 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
125 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AA24 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/07/389/006
MA holder
BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB PHARMA EEIG
MA country
Iceland
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

ORENCIA 87.5 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD7240789 · Product

Active substance
Abatacept
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
125 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
125 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AA24 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/07/389/014
MA holder
BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB PHARMA EEIG
MA country
EU
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Tyenne 162mg/0.9ml solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD10827693 · Product

Active substance
Tocilizumab
Substance synonyms
RO4877533, BIIB800, ATLIZUMAB, TOCILIZUMABUM
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
162 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
162 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AC07 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/23/1754/007
MA holder
FRESENIUS KABI DEUTSCHLAND GMBH
MA country
EU
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Comparator 4

Enbrel 25 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD6538806 · Product

Active substance
Etanercept
Substance synonyms
CHS-0214, ETANERCEPT (GENETICAL RECOMBINATION)
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
50 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
50 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AB01 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/99/126/013
MA holder
PFIZER EUROPE MA EEIG
MA country
EU
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Enbrel 50 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD6538810 · Product

Active substance
Etanercept
Substance synonyms
CHS-0214, ETANERCEPT (GENETICAL RECOMBINATION)
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
50 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
50 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AB01 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/99/126/018
MA holder
PFIZER EUROPE MA EEIG
MA country
EU
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Humira 40 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD5952365 · Product

Active substance
Adalimumab
Substance synonyms
ABP 501, BI 695501, MSB11022
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
40 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
40 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AB04 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/03/256/012
MA holder
ABBVIE DEUTSCHLAND GMBH & CO. KG
MA country
EU
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Humira 20 mg solution for injection in pre-filled syringe

PRD5956787 · Product

Active substance
Adalimumab
Substance synonyms
ABP 501, BI 695501, MSB11022
Pharmaceutical form
SOLUTION FOR INJECTION
Route of administration
SUBCUTANEOUS
Max daily dose
40 mg milligram(s)
Max total dose
40 mg milligram(s)
Max treatment duration
12 Month(s)
Authorisation status
Authorised
ATC code
L04AB04 — -
Marketing authorisation
EU/1/03/256/022
MA holder
ABBVIE DEUTSCHLAND GMBH & CO. KG
MA country
Norway
Paediatric formulation
No
Orphan designation
No
Modified vs. Marketing Authorisation
No

Sponsors and contacts

Sponsor organisations, regulatory contacts, third parties

Duke Clinical Research Institute

Sponsor organisation
Duke Clinical Research Institute
Address
2400 Pratt Street
City
Durham
Postcode
27705-3976
Country
United States

Scientific contact point

Organisation
Duke Clinical Research Institute
Contact name
IRCCS Istituto Giannina Gaslini, delegated by the Sponsor

Public contact point

Organisation
Duke Clinical Research Institute
Contact name
IRCCS Istituto Giannina Gaslini, delegated by the Sponsor

Locations

3 EU/EEA countries · 3 investigational sites

By country

CountryMS statusPlanned subjectsSites
Germany Authorised, recruitment pending 15 1
Italy Authorised, recruitment pending 15 1
Netherlands Authorised, recruitment pending 15 1
Rest of world
United States
45

Investigational sites

Germany

1 site · Authorised, recruitment pending
Asklepios Klinik Sankt Augustin GmbH
Center for General Paediatrics and Neonatology, Arnold-Janssen-Strasse 29, 53757, Sankt Augustin

Italy

1 site · Authorised, recruitment pending
IRCCS Istituto Giannina Gaslini
U.O.C. Reumatologia e Malattie Autoinfiammatorie, Via Gerolamo Gaslini 5, 16147, Genoa

Netherlands

1 site · Authorised, recruitment pending
Universitair Medisch Centrum Utrecht
Pediatric Rheumatology and Immunology, Lundlaan 6, 3584 EA, Utrecht

Results and documents

Annex IV summary of results, Annex V layperson summary, and all documents registered in CTIS for this trial

Documents 72 files

Public protocol annexes, IB summaries, regulatory submissions and post-authorisation documents registered in CTIS.

TypeTitleVersion
Protocol (for publication) D1_Protocol 2025-520923-25-00 1.3.1
Protocol (for publication) D4_PROMIS Pediatric_Global_Health 7_Italian_06Jun2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaire_PROMIS Pediatric_Pain Interference 8a_German_14Mar2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaireJAMARchi_Dutch 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaireJAMARchi_German 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaireJAMARchi_Italian 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaireJAMARpar_Dutch 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaireJAMARpar_German 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnaireJAMARpar_Italian 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy Scale_Global Health 7_ Italian_05Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_ Global Health 7_Dutch_11Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Anxiety 8a_Dutch_2Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Anxiety 8a_German_11Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Anxiety 8a_Italian_05Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Depressive Symptoms 6a_Dutch_2Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Depressive Symptoms 6a_German_11Nov24 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Depressive Symptoms 6a_Italian_5Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Fatigue 10a_Dutch_13Dec2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Fatigue 10a_German_07Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Fatigue 10a_Italian_07Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Global Health 7_German_11Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Mobility 7a_Dutch_13Dec2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Mobility 7a_German_08Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Mobility 7a_Italian_8Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Pain Interference 8a_Dutch_11Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Pain Interference 8a_German_07Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Pain Interference 8a_Italian_05Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Upper Extremity 8a_Dutch_12Dec2023 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Upper Extremity 8a_German_02Dec2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Parent Proxy_Upper Extremity 8a_Italian_05Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Anxiety 8a_Dutch_12Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Anxiety 8a_German_11Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Anxiety 8a_Italian_05Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Depressive Symptoms 8a_Dutch_17Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Depressive Symptoms 8a_German_11Nov24 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Depressive Symptoms 8a_Italian_05Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Fatigue 10a_Dutch_17Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Fatigue 10a_German_14Mar2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Fatigue 10a_Italian_19Mar2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Global Health 7_Dutch_30May2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Global Health 7_German_06Jun2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Mobility 7a_Dutch_10Jun2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Mobility 7a_German_08Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Mobility 7a_Italian_8Jan2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Pain Interference 8a_Dutch_10Jun2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Pain Interference 8a_Italian_20Mar2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Upper Extremity 8a_Dutch_12Dec2023 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Upper Extremity 8a_German_11Nov2024 3
Protocol (for publication) D4_questionnairePROMIS Pediatric_Upper Extremity 8a_Italian_05Nov2024 3
Recruitment arrangements (for publication) K1_Recruitment arrangements_DE 2
Recruitment arrangements (for publication) K1_Recruitment arrangements_IT 1
Recruitment arrangements (for publication) K1_Recruitment arrangements_NL 2
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_12-16 yrs_NL 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_12-17 yrs_IT 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_13-17 yrs_DE 1.2
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_6-11 yrs_IT 1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_6-11 yrs_NL 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_7-12 yrs_DE 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_adult patient_DE 1.3
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_adult patient_NL 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_adult_IT 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_parent-guardian_DE 1.3
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_parent-guardian_IT 1.1
Subject information and informed consent form (for publication) L1_SIS and ICF_parent-guardian_NL 1.1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) E2_SmPC_abatacept 1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) E2_SmPC_adalimumab 1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) E2_SmPC_etanercept 1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) E2_SmPC_tocilizumab 1
Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC) (for publication) E2_SmPC_tofacitinib 1
Synopsis of the protocol (for publication) D1_Protocol synopsis DE 2025-520923-25-00 1.3
Synopsis of the protocol (for publication) D1_Protocol synopsis IT 2025-520923-25-00 1.3
Synopsis of the protocol (for publication) D1_Protocol synopsis NL 2025-520923-25-00 1.3

Application history

2 submissions — initial application plus substantial / non-substantial modifications

#TypeCodeSubmittedReference MSConclusionDecision date
1 INITIAL IN 2025-10-06 Italy Acceptable
2026-02-09
2026-02-10
2 NON SUBSTANTIAL MODIFICATION NSM-1 2026-02-24 Acceptable
2026-02-09
2026-02-24